Ratings and reviews
Jimtown Pizza Photos
Hours
| Monday |
Jimtown Pizza Reviews
Lived in the area for a year and always wanted to try it here, was not disappointed. Everything here is homemade and so yummy
I'm a pizza snob. This is damn good pizza. Lots of cheese and toppings. Sauce is a little bland but still good. I will be ordering from here again because I love supporting local businesses. It's definitely worth trying.
I've been eating here for years, the pizza is awesome, they have ice cream, the service is great. They take check and cash, no debit cards or credit cards. Do wish they had green olives and banana peppers. You won't be disappointed.
This place has good pizza, the downside of getting pizza here is its a bit pricey... The local take-to-go pizza is neat. There are some benches outside that you can sit on to cool off with some good ice cream after a bike ride, walk, or however you got here.
Love J town pizza, a unique pizza that does not taste like the run of the mill pizza. Yeah it's a little greasy, but that is part of the charm that makes it perfect. Love the little stone faced building that it's in, so small you can barely turn around in, haha. The kids always have to get ice cream there as well. Really fairly priced... No delivery, but it's Jimtown, can't be that far right!? Do miss the old huge tree that came down in front though , it was like a landmark....
The pizza here is okay... Tasty but expensive. But, the ice cream here is great! I come here sometimes, for the pizza and ice cream... But mostly for the ice cream.
What a great local place. Not much to look at on the outside, but the oven is cranking out great pizzas. The staff have been there long term. The girls who make the pizzas on Thursday night make a great pizza. The ice cream is also crazy good with flavors constantly rotating. Bring cash as they are a little old school. Enjoy a hidden gem in Baugo Township.
This place has big servings of ice cream for cheap its amazing the pizza and subs are great looks kinda sketchy but you have to try it it's great
Jimtown Pizza
Jimtown Pizza is a must-visit destination, nestled at 59176 Co Rd 3, Elkhart, IN 46517, this local favorite combines a warm, welcoming atmosphere with delicious, handcrafted pizzas that leave a lasting impression.
Jimtown Pizza Brings a Slice of Joy to Elkhart
The heart and soul of Jimtown Pizza lie in its ability to create a perfect slice every time. Their pizzas are crafted with fresh, high-quality ingredients, ensuring every bite bursts with flavor. Whether you prefer a classic cheese pizza or something more adventurous, Jimtown’s menu caters to all taste buds. Each pizza is made with a thin yet perfectly crisp crust, topped with generous portions of toppings, and baked to perfection.
Handcrafted Pizzas and More at Jimtown Pizza
While pizza takes center stage, Jimtown Pizza also offers a variety of other menu items to round out your dining experience. Their breadsticks are the perfect start to any meal, paired with marinara or cheese sauce for dipping. If you’re in the mood for something lighter, their fresh salads provide a refreshing complement to the rich flavors of their pizzas.
Jimtown Pizza knows how to balance simplicity and creativity, ensuring there’s something for everyone on the menu.
Jimtown Pizza’s Cozy and Family-Friendly Atmosphere
One of the standout features of Jimtown Pizza is its inviting and family-friendly ambiance. The restaurant is designed to feel like a home away from home, making it the perfect spot for a relaxed dinner with family or friends. From the friendly staff to the cozy decor, every detail is crafted to ensure you feel welcome the moment you walk in.
Experience Exceptional Service at Jimtown Pizza
The team at Jimtown Pizza goes above and beyond to make every visit memorable. Their attentive service ensures that your order is just the way you like it, and the staff is always happy to offer recommendations. It’s this commitment to customer satisfaction that keeps locals coming back for more and earns the praise of newcomers.
Jimtown Pizza’s hours are designed to cater to your evening cravings. Open from 4:00 PM to 9:00 PM Tuesday through Sunday, you can enjoy their mouthwatering pizzas during the perfect dinner hours. The restaurant is closed on Mondays, giving their hardworking team a well-deserved break. For reservations or inquiries, you can reach Jimtown Pizza phone number +1 574-295-5142.
What Sets Jimtown Pizza Apart from Other Pizzerias
Jimtown Pizza isn’t just another pizza joint; it’s a community staple that prioritizes quality, flavor, and a welcoming environment. Their dedication to using fresh ingredients, combined with the artistry of their pizza-making, ensures a consistently great dining experience. Whether you’re a local or just passing through Elkhart, Jimtown Pizza offers a slice of joy that’s hard to find elsewhere.
They make the best pizza in the area! Also lots of good fried items to go with! They are CASH or CHECK only so make sure to come prepared but the food is so worth it! If you're looking for a genuinely good pizza from a local mom and pop place don't pass up on Jimtown Pizza!